3S Living River Edition 4

News from the Sesan, Srepok and Sekong Rivers in Cambodia

Notes from the editor:

Dear friends, welcome to the fourth edition of ‘Living Rivers’, our new quarterly newsletter which we hope you will enjoy reading.

The Sesan, Srepok and Sekong (3S) Rivers in north-eastern Cambodia contribute more than fifteen percent of the Mekong’s water flow and are representatives of important and biologically diverse ecosystem types.

The 3S Region is also home to numerous minority groups and indigenous people including; Brov, Jarai, Kachok, Kavet, Kreung, Kreung Lon, Lao and Tampoun. Riverside communities in the 3S Region have always starts stated that their way of life has been dependant on the wild rivers’ resources which include fresh water, fish, other aquatic fauna, and wild vegetables.

We aim to bring to your attention information regarding 3S communities, including hydropower development issues, and other conservation and environmental news relevant to 3S villagers and the region as a whole. We anticipate that this broad regional
approach will be able to make a contribution to, and raise awareness of hydropower projects and their likely environmental and social costs both locally and nationally.

Download Living Rivers Volume 4 (English)

Download Living Rivers Volume 4 (Khmer)

Posted in biodiversity, Cambodia, community voices, conservation, flora and fauna, health, hydropower, The Sesan River, Tributary of The Mekong, Vietnam | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Cambodian Women Speak Up on Dam’s Threat

By Amy Lieberman for WeNews

In Cambodia’s rural northeastern province, the Sesan River is the primary source of food and income for fishing and farming communities. But hydropower dams are encroaching and village women say their daily life is hit the hardest.

RATANAKIRI PROVINCE, Cambodia -The Cambodian government has not yet secured funding for Lower Sesan 2, a 750 megawatt, $650 million dam that would export electricity to Vietnam and become the largest hydropower dam in Cambodia.

With plans underway, though, some women in the deeply spiritual nine ethnic indigenous communities of Ratanakiri Province, 10 hours north of Phnom Penh, are braced for the worst.

Ratanakiri residents along the Sesan river support themselves by fishing and farming, both subject to drastic disruption by the project. The dam is expected to impinge on fish migration and flood surrounding farmland.

On Si Kan is “spirit chief” of her community of about 250, a position typically held by Lao ethnic women who channel male spirits. She has already given up any thought of fighting the dam, planned for 80 miles downstream.

“I tell people we can do nothing to stop the project. The government will build the dam,” said On, 57, through a Khmer translator. “So the people can wait for the dam to come and they can die in the floods it will cause, or they can move away from the river.”

At the same time as women such as On are resigned, others are leading community opposition, says Ian Baird, a University of Wisconsin, Madison, professor of geography and fisheries. Baird has worked in the region for more than 25 years.

“When people from Ratanakiri come down to Phnom Penh to talk, many of them are really intimidated,” he said. “But it’s the women who are asking the most powerful questions, even as everyone is 100-percent afraid to speak out.”

Ratanakiri representatives attended a national consultation on Sesan 2 at the end of May in Phnom Penh where the environmental minister, Prach Sun, highlighting project benefits.

“It will help bring Cambodia development and reduce poverty,” Prach said. “This will contribute to the resources of Cambodia and to its people. That is the most important thing.”

Distrusting the Process

Hor Voy South, a 56-year-old mother of eight, is a community organizer for 3S Rivers Protection Network, or 3SPN, which supports communities threatened by hydropower dams in northeastern Cambodia. She attended the consultation in Phnom Penh and says she doubts the meeting will help.

“The community talks and the government listens, but nothing changes,” she said. “We say, ‘We don’t want the government to build the dam here,’ but we think they will build it anyway.”

The sense of powerlessness among communities of Ratanakiri Province, 10 hours north of Phnom Penh, derives from what happened after another dam was built on the same river.

Yali Falls, a 720 megawatt hydropower dam, was established in 1996 on a part of the Sesan that is in central Vietnam, approximately 100 miles upstream from Ratanakiri.

The Yali construction caused flooding of land hundreds of miles away and hindered the migratory passage of the fish locals depended on for food and income.

Hydropower dams are sprouting up across Southeast Asia. Twenty seven are now operating in China, Laos, Thailand, Vietnam and Cambodia; nine are being built and 14 are proposed. Hydropower dams produce one of the most common forms of renewable electricity, while releasing a very low rate of greenhouse gas emissions.

They also create havoc to traditional livelihoods. Upstream, the rivers back up and cause flooding. Downstream, the water volume is constrained, threatening aquatic life.

Water around hydro-dams is also prone to producing algae that can be poisonous or degrade water qualities in other ways.

Spirit Chief Moved to Higher Ground

After Spirit Chief On’s property flooded multiple times following Yali’s construction, she moved several miles away inland from the river in 2006.

Displacement like this, she said, was particularly hard on women who may have to seek out new, unfamiliar sources of food for their families inland and travel farther to find water.

While male villagers customarily do the fishing, women clean clothes and bathe children and draw water from it. After a dam, the river’s flows become unstable and threatening. Women say their constant contacts with the river are now riddled with anxiety, especially when they consider the possibility that a giant dam could break.

“The floods come and destroy the farms and it becomes difficult for women, who have to do all of the work. Then we have to move to high land, and there we don’t know where to find food,” said the spirit chief.

On her dry patch of land it’s difficult to grow food and there isn’t always enough to feed the five people in her house. But at least she’s not worried about flooding.

Im Yim Krub, 35, by contrast, still worries about flooding. She lives about 20 feet from the river, a few miles away from the spirit chief’s land. In 2009 the river filled her house and attached convenient store with 4 feet of water. She fled on motorcycle with her husband and four children and stayed with relatives in the mountains for weeks.

“I think always if that could happen again this year. I have become afraid of the river and how it can rise so quickly,” said Im, who does not let her children play in the river unsupervised.

Im sells bottled water for 25 cents, though she herself relies on a nearby well for drinking water. But many residents, like Hor Voy South, a 56-year-old mother of eight, drink from and bathe in the dirt-colored river.

Hor and one of her sons have developed skin infections in the past 10 years and often suffer diarrhea. She, like more than 40 percent of all Cambodians, lives on less than $1.25 a day.

More than 1,000 people in Ratanakiri have died since 1996 as a result of poor water quality, according to University of Wisconsin’s Baird.

Yali Falls’ downstream impact in Cambodia has caused serious ecological and social-economic problems for approximately 20,000 Ratanakiri residents and tens of thousands of people farther down the river. Aside from flooding and health problems, loss of fish and vegetables have also lowered people’s regular incomes and food intakes. People in Ratanakiri have not received financial compensation for their health problems or income losses.

If Lower Sesan 2 is built, Ratanakiri residents will receive a one-time lump-sum payment to cover a single year for fish losses.

Source

Visit WeNews

Posted in biodiversity, Cambodia, community voices, conservation, finance, flooding, flora and fauna, health, hydropower, The Sesan River, Tributary of The Mekong | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Electricity for Vietnam

By Adam Miller and Phak Seangly for The Phnom Penh Post

An official from the Ministry of Environment admitted yesterday that electricity generated from the controversial Lower Sesan 2 Dam, a project touted as ensuring cheaper energy prices in Cambodia, would be exported to Vietnam.

The admission, made at an NGO-led workshop held with indigenous community representatives in Phnom Penh, came after a United States-based fisheries expert and consultant for conservation group International Rivers estimated that only about 1 percent of the dam’s capacity would be used locally, with the rest being sold to Cambodia’s eastern neighbour.

The proposed US$816 million, 400-megawatt dam is set to begin construction later this year in Stung Treng province by the Cambodia-Vietnam Hydropower Company, a joint venture that is 51-percent owned by the EVNI Joint Stock Company of Vietnam and 49-percent owned by local conglomerate the Royal Group.

Prach Sun, a secretary of state for the Ministry of Environment, initially said yesterday that the potential of the Lower Sesan 2 Dam to fulfill local energy needs outweighed the environmental and social damage it may inflict on indigenous communities.

“The development of the Lower Sesan 2 Dam will have some effects on natural resources, but electricity is the most important resource for the country and we must ensure the development of hydroelectric dams will be achieved,” he said at the event, which was attended by over 60 villager representatives from Rattanakiri and Stung Treng who say they will be affected by the project.

“The relocation of people and the price of electricity decreasing will contribute to the development of the country,” Prach Sun said.

Danh Serey, deputy director of the Environment Impact Assessment department at the Ministry of Environment, echoed these comments, stressing the need for increased energy supplies in Cambodia.

“Cambodia needs electricity, we need to develop electric areas, and hydropower is much better than other sources – this is why the Lower Sesan 2 Dam is so important,” he said.

Yet the forum took an unexpected turn when fisheries expert and NGO consultant Ian Baird said that there was no evidence to support the claims that the electricity generated would be used in Cambodia.

“The plan of the company is to export all of this electricity to Vietnam,” he said.

“So I don’t know why we are talking about this [electricity] as being used in Cambodia,” he said, adding that Cambodia will be unable to even make use of the 400MW of power from the project without a national electrical grid. “This is not about electricity for Cambodia. It is not about reducing the cost of electricity in Cambodia,” Baird said. “They are trying to maximise their profit. It’s not for the benefit of the country – these are private companies.”

The comments prompted one representative from the Ministry of Environment to quickly change his stance.

Danh Serey later claimed that exporting the electricity to Vietnam was the second step of the process, after the energy needs of local communities in northeast Cambodia had been met.

“The Ministry of Environment has observed the situation closely. Only the left-over electricity from the use of local people will be sold to Vietnam,” he said following the event.

Baird said only a miniscule amount of the energy generated would be used locally.

“Maybe a very small amount of electricity they might use around Stung Treng, but it would be less than 1 percent,” he said, adding that the province could likely all be powered off of only 1MW of energy.

“It’s obvious the power is not for Cambodia because there is too much and there is no way to distribute it,” he said.

“The question is, what benefit is Cambodia getting? What is the Cambodian government getting in terms of taxes or concession fees?” he continued.

Royal Group Chairman Kith Meng declined to comment, referring questions to the Ministry of Industry, Mines and Energy.

Royal Group chief financial officer Mark Hanna could not be reached for comment yesterday.

In a statement released in April, Kith Meng said that the project “will contribute greatly to the continued economic development of Cambodia, ensuring a reliable, moderately-priced supply of electricity”.

Source

Visit The Phnom Penh Post

Posted in Cambodia, community voices, finance, flora and fauna, hydropower, The Sesan River, Tributary of The Mekong, Vietnam | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Flood of hydrodam fears

In Ratanakkiri province with May Titthara and Adam Miller for The Phnom Penh Post

Hundreds of villagers from communities along the Sesan river met in Ratanakkiri’s Veun Sai district yesterday to protest against the planned US$700 million Lower Sesan II dam, which they believe could destroy their livelihoods.

Roughly 270 villagers from Ratanakkiri, Mondulkiri, Stung Treng and Kratie provinces met at an NGO-led forum in Pong commune to voice discontent over the hydroelectric project, set be built about 40 kilometres from Stung Treng town.

Construction on the 400-megawatt dam – which is a joint venture between Cambodia’s Royal Group and EVNI Joint Stock Company of Vietnam – is due to start later this year.

Chhith Sam Ath, executive director of NGO Forum, an event co-organiser, said yesterday that the meeting was crucial in allowing communities to express their concerns. “The river is our life because it supports the villagers’ standard of living,” he said.

If constructed, he added, the dam could affect more than 1,500 families living in the region who rely on the river for fish and growing rice, in addition to flooding more than 30,000 hectares of forest.

Meach Mean, project coordinator of the 3S Rivers Protection Network, another organiser of yesterday’s meeting, said an environmental impact assessment of the scheme had ignored a raft of considerations including indirect impacts to upstream communities, including changes in fish migration and breeding patterns.

“Based on the impact of Yali Falls dam in Vietnam, the fish stocks have [already] decreased markedly, and that will be exacerbated significantly by a second dam,” he said, adding that agricultural output in downstream communities would also be affected.

“Their farming areas will have to change and that will negatively impact their livelihoods and food security as well,” he said.

During the event, which began with ethnic Tampoun villagers performing a cultural dance as village elders drank from a ceramic jug of rice wine, community representatives gave passionate speeches about the project’s potential fallout for their communities.

Sai Bun Pom, a representative for Sesan district’s Kbal Romea commune in Stung Treng province, told The Post that he had come to the public assembly to grab the attention of government officials over the villagers’ situation.

His community has faced hardships in recent years due to similar projects, he said, pointing in particular to the 720MW Yali Falls dam, 80 kilometres upstream of the Cambodian border.

“We have been suffering every year because of the Yali Falls dam in Vietnam, which is not even in our country. What will happen to us if they construct the dam in our country? We will lose everything,” he said.

In 2000, at least five Cambodians were killed, crops destroyed and fishing boats and equipment lost after a massive release of water from the Yali Falls dam, which caused sudden surges in the volume and current downstream on the Sesan in Cambodia.

Kham Kang, a representative from Sesan district, said that the serious problems caused by the Yali Falls dam would only be exacerbated by the Lower Sesan II. She added that villagers’ livelihoods had already been affected by the decrease in fish stocks stemming from the construction at Yali.

“We never had these kinds of issues before,” she said. “I hope that the government will solve our issues.”

The solidarity of the various communities continued after the meeting, when villagers marched down a one-kilometre dirt road in Pong commune, carrying banners and chanting slogans emphasising the importance of the river to their respective communities.

Once they reached the Sesan riverside, the group released about 15,000 fish spawn to increase future stocks. They also prayed for the future prosperity of those living along the river, while monks blessed the ceremony.

Paov Horm Phan, Ratanakkiri provincial governor, said yesterday that the Sesan dam was not a large concern for the province as it was downstream in Stung Treng. The dam would allow villagers to have an ample supply of usable water, he said.

Puth Sorithy, director of the environmental impact assessment department of the Environment Ministry, declined to comment yesterday, as did Meng Savuth, the ministry’s cabinet director.

Royal Group chairman Kith Meng declined to comment, referring questions to the Ministry of Industry, Mines and Energy.

In a Royal Group statement last month, he said that the project would “contribute greatly to the economic development of Cambodia”.

Source

Visit The Phnom Penh Post

Additional reporting by David Boyle.

Posted in biodiversity, Cambodia, community voices, finance, flora and fauna, hydropower, The Sesan River, Tributary of The Mekong, Vietnam | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Sesan dam to proceed this year

By Tom Brennan and Sen David for The Phnom Penh Post

CAMBODIA’S Royal Group announced yesterday that it would proceed with its Vietnamese partner on a US$700 million hydroelectric plant along the Lower Sesan River, with construction due to start by the end of the year.

The 400 megawatt Sesan hydro plant will be located 40 kilometres northwest of the town of Stung Treng and is expected to enter commercial operations in 2017, a Royal Group statement said.

“This power generation project will contribute greatly to the continued economic development of Cambodia, ensuring a reliable, moderately-priced supply of electricity,” said Royal Group Kith Meng in the statement.

The joint venture – called the Cambodia-Vietnam Hydropower Company – is 51 percent owned by EVNI Joint Stock Company of Vietnam, with the remainder held by Royal Group, officials said earlier this year. The venture was officially established yesterday at the 2nd Cambodia-Vietnam Conference on Investment Promotion at Phnom Penh’s Peace Palace, where a number of deals were signed.

Negotiations for the supply of electricity are presently underway, Kith Meng said yesterday, adding they were “about 90 percent finished already.”

Royal Group said in the statement that project studies are complete.

The impact of large-scale hydroelectricity projects has been a contentious issues in the Kingdom.

Chith Sam Ath, Executive Director of NGO Forum, urged the joint venture to learn from what he saw as the problems caused by other dams. One in particular, the Yali Falls Damn in Vietnam, “created a lot of negative impact for the people who live downstream,” he said.

Kith Meng declined to discuss the venture’s environmental impact assessment yesterday and referred questions to government officials.

Officials from the Environment Ministry declined comment yesterday. EVNI had valued the cost of the project at $806 million in a 2010 statement on its website.

Source

Visit The Phnom Penh Post

Posted in biodiversity, Cambodia, flora and fauna, hydropower, The Sesan River, Vietnam | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

30% Of Ratanakiri Is Contracted To Foreign Companies For Mineral Exploration

This extract is translated from Khmer press into English…

The Mirror, Vol. 14, No. 678

“The rich natural resources in Cambodia, especially gold, gems, and diamonds, attract the attention from foreign investors to invest in mining in Cambodia, and the leading companies are the OZ Company and Southern Gold company of Australia. Also, some Yuon [Vietnamese] companies that do not make their identity known, operating illegally on gold exploitation, siphoning national resources out from Cambodia.

“The Yuon press quoted the director of the Saigon Jewelry Company, the biggest gold company in Vietnam, Mr. Nguyen Thanh Long [Nguyễn Thành Long], as having said that the company had shown its plan to the Yuon government to ask for permission to invest in factories in Cambodia and Laos. If this company earns the approval from the Yuon government or from the governments where it plans to invest, this company will establish gold manufacturing factories abroad not later than in late 2010.

“Yuon officials said that this company will start its production with the trademark SJC in Laos this year, investing in Laos first, before seeking to create factories and branches in Cambodia. Some other Yuon companies investing in gold trade, such as the Sacom Bank, the Agri-Bank, and the Hun Huang [? - phonetic], and have opened representative offices in Cambodia and are strengthening and expanding their business operations.

“Yuon investors see huge benefits from investments in Cambodia and in gold exploration in the northeast of Cambodia; they have sent skilled workers to come to conduct illegal exploitation with the backing from military officials or civil authorities. Gold deposits in the northeast of Cambodia are being exploited illegally by traders, not leading to national income.

“Recently, Yuon traders had sent a barge on the Sekong river to Siem Pang district in Stung Treng, loaded with gold filtering machines, in an attempt to conduct illegal gold exploitation. The local authorities blocked the barge for some time to clarify questions about legal documents, but they will likely let it go after an intervention from the provincial level.

“Also, citizens in the Veun Sai district in Ratanakiri are worrying about the impact on water quality in the Sesan river, as Chinese gold miners are drilling to explore gold ore on Pang Island. They said that the Chinese company has been operating for two months, employing more than 10 Khmer workers, using two machines for drilling, and disposing waste water into the Sesan river, from which citizens consume water for their daily living.

“Citizens complained that at present, the water in the Sesan river was dirty and can no longer be used, but the local authorities do not intervene. Pang Island in the Sesan river has an area of 200 meter in length and 100 meter in width, and there live Krueng ethnic minority tribespeople, who have settled there since long. Now they are seriously affected by the gold exploitation by the Chinese company Indochine Resources [a holding company for the Indochine Group, 'the largest mineral concession holder in The Royal Kingdom of Cambodia' - including Indochine Mining].

“Officials of the Ministry of Industry. Ratanakiri Department, said that the Ministry of Industry provided a license to Indochine Resources in November 2009, to explore metal ore on an area of 200 square kilometers. So far, no companies have been registered also to exploit resources. All are just conducting explorations, and any exploitation in the past was illegal.

Read article…

Visit The Mirror

Posted in biodiversity, community voices, health, Laos, mining, pollution, The Sesan River, Tributary of The Mekong, Vietnam | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Ministry told to monitor environment at hydropower plants

Vietnam Business News

The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment has just been urged by the Government to monitor environmental impact at hydropower projects that are under construction nationwide, said Deputy Minister Nguyen Thai Lai.

Lai said last week that Deputy Prime Minister Hoang Trung Hai had asked the ministry to make closer inspections at hydropower plants and impose heavier fines on developers who fail to reforest after construction or that contribute to disturbing water flow in damned rivers’ lower sections.

According to the Ministry of Industry and Trade, the development of some hydropower projects in Central Vietnam and the Central Highlands has negatively affected the regions, both environmentally and socially.

Some hydropower project developers have reluctantly obeyed environment protection and dam security regulations.

“Developers of all approved hydropower projects must submit environmental impact assessments before they begin construction; however many developers have ignored the requirements,” Lai said, adding that many barely took notice of the Ministry’s appraisal and the potential consequences before building dams and reservoirs.

To protect water sources in the rivers where there are dams, Lai said that the Government had just issued a decree on the overall management of irrigation reservoirs and hydropower plants to reduce negative environmental impacts and pollution as well as to maintain normal river flows.

Read article…

Visit Vietnam Business News

Posted in biodiversity, conservation, flooding, hydropower, Tributary of The Mekong, Vietnam | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Daming the future of villages on the banks of the Sesan river

David Boyle for The Phnom Penh Post

AT about six o’clock in the evening on Monday 28, September 2009, Ru Chom watched helplessly as a wall of water surged through her riverside village, uprooting her house and washing away livestock, trees and wild animals.

“The money that I had earned I spent on the previous house. I hadn’t even finished it yet and now it is upside down. Now I have nothing and no business,” she said, pointing to the remnants of her former home.

Typhoon Ketsana had struck, bringing a torrent of water with it and while the nation’s eyes were fixated on the tragic floods in Kampong Thom province, further north in Ratanakkiri province another catastrophe was quietly unfolding.

Two hours earlier at the Yali Falls Dam, 900 kilometres east in neighbouring Vietnam, desperate officials had opened the floodgates of smaller regulation dams, fearing the dam walls would collapse under intense pressure from the floods.

The dams simply hadn’t been built to withstand the pressure of torrential downpours on the scale of Ketsana, and shortly after the gates were opened Ratanakkiri provincial Governor Pav Hamphan received a phone call, warning him of the impending flood.

Read article…

Visit The Phnom Penh Post

Posted in community voices, flooding, hydropower, Tributary of The Mekong | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Villagers write to Hun Sen over dam

By DAVID BOYLE AND PHAK SEANGLY for The Phnom Penh Post

REPRESENTATIVES of 74 indigenous minority villages in Ratanakkiri province have prepared a letter calling on Prime Minister Hun Sen to halt construction of a dam that they say will devastate the flow and biodiversity of the Sesan River, endangering the livelihoods of tens of thousands, a plea timed to coincide with the premier’s scheduled visit to the province this week.

The letter is to be delivered to provincial officials today, two days after the launch of a weeklong trade fair in the province intended to facilitate investment opportunities in the so-called “development triangle” of neighbouring border areas in Cambodia, Thailand and Laos.

Meach Mien, project coordinator of the 3S Rivers Protection Network, said Sunday that Hun Sen was expected to arrive in Ratanakkiri this week to formally open National Road 78, though officials could not confirm the details of the visit.

Read article…

Visit Phnom Penh Post

Posted in biodiversity, Cambodia, community voices, conservation, flora and fauna, hydropower, Tributary of The Mekong | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Closed dams a headache for fishermen

CAMERON WELLS AND THA PISETH for The Phnom Penh Post

River conservation advocates said Wednesday that the closing of dams in Vietnam had caused the Sesan River in northeast Cambodia to become so dry that it was occasionally possible to walk from one side to the other, and that fluctuating water levels were threatening villagers dependent on the river’s fish.

The 3S Rivers Protection Network (3SPN) said in a statement that the water shortage in the Sesan – particularly in the O’Yadav and Andong Meas districts of Ratanakkiri province – had been caused by the Yali Falls hydroelectric dam, located 80 kilometres from the Cambodian border, as well as five other dams in Vietnam.

Sev Doeun, a spokesman for 3SPN, said in an interview that the recent temporary closures of the Yali Falls dam had not only threatened fishermen’s livelihoods, but had also made some of them ill.

“On February 2, they closed the dam and prevented the water from flowing,” he said. “When the water wasn’t flowing, the young people were getting rashes. Also, when it was low, the people found it hard to row and fish.”

Their problems didn’t end when the dam was reopened on Tuesday, he added.

“When the water was low, they had to leave the boats on the riverbed, but when it reopened the boats floated away,” he said. “The fishermen couldn’t find them. The people were [also] scared when it reopened because there could be flooding.”

Concerns in Vietnam
The 3SPN statement follows a forum held at Vietnam’s Can Tho University on February 3 at which experts said they were worried that dams built on the Mekong would disrupt fish migrations “that are critical to the life cycle of 70 percent of the Mekong’s commercial fish catch” in Vietnam.

Experts expressed concern about plans for the construction of 11 further hydropower dams on separate Mekong tributaries, which they said would affect water quality and cause riverbank erosion.

Ratanakkiri provincial officials said they were too busy to comment on Wednesday.

[Ed -Apols for full quote]

Source

Posted in Cambodia, health, hydropower, Tributary of The Mekong | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment